Friday, October 26, 2007
Tacchino Ciclicross
Don't miss stop #5 of the BikeReg.com MABRA Cross Series. It's Sunday, November 4th at Ida Lee Park in Leesburg.
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
Tuesday, October 23, 2007
MAC Standings after Week 1
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
E-Town had a great day on Saturday, but for whatever reason couldn't follow that up on Sunday. In both cases, he took the holeshot as expected and put a hurtin' on the field. Whether or not he can sustain that for back-to-back days is something we'll be following in the final two MAC weekends. If he plans to stay on Linder's tail, he can't fade. I think we're seeing a renewed E-town, one with more focus and desire than ever before, but a letdown after the spectacle of Granogue probably caught up to him. If anyone is capable of beating Linder, Townsend made it clear that he's the closest.
My pick to win, Ellicott, didn't have his best day and the rust showed. Poor tire selection, bad legs, and discomfort with a front row start all factored in. Research will likely keep Ellicott from being a factor in the overall series, but even in limited appearances, he always has a shot to steal a victory.
By far the biggest surprise of the weekend was the incredible riding by the youngest in the field, Jeff Bahnson. He was the darling of the crowds and the annoucer both days. On Saturday, he made the most of his third row start and worked his way up through the field to take fifth. His handling skills are obviously quite advanced, but his engine also seems to be more than enough to ride in the Killer B's. What a season this young'un may have, it's entirely possible he could be the youngest winner of MAC B race in recent memory. The DCCoD has its rider for the near and distant future. Count me and the whole field as very much impressed.
Just behind Bahnson in terms of consistency over both days were South Boston's Jeremy Dunn and NYC's Matt Budd. Dunn showed the form that made him this year's top returner in terms of points scored over a full season. Consistency did it for him last year and it appears we'll be seeing much of the same if he continues to travel South. Budd, who was mistakenly overlooked in the Granogue preview, rode to a seventh place finish on both days, the only NY rider to make the top ten.
Jeremy Dunn's teammate, Pete Smith had a fantastic ride at Granogue, where he finished fourth. In not contesting the next day's race, he fell in the standings of course, but he made it known that when he comes into the MAC he's one to watch. Another rider only contesting the first day was Mike Stubna of GPOA. He finished a solid ninth place in his first 'cross race in two years. He too would have factored in on a Wissahickon course that was less technical and more suited to his roadie skills.
Team Beacon ran into a string of bad luck this weekend. Front row starter Daniel Brill missed his call-up and was relegated to the back of the field on Saturday--a catastrophic start to the MAC campaign. Still, he managed to take 16th and limit the damage. On Sunday, it was 17-year-old Patrick Bradley's turn to experience bad luck. After an official took issue with his riding on the course during an earlier race, he was relegated back a few rows from his top starting spot. In the melee of the start at Wissahickon, he got caught up in a crash and destroyed his front wheel, breaking several spokes and forcing him to run to the pit. A quick change still put him far back and 21st was the best he could manage. That's a tough pill to swallow a day after finishing on the podium at Granogue.
Speaking of disasters, it wasn't only Team Beacon who had their share. At Granogue, both Kevin Kralik and newcomer Turner Johnson fell victim to mechanical issues. Kralik went down with an issue before the first lap was even complete. It appears he spent a while trying to fix the problem, but wasn't able to get things working. Johnson had chain issues of his own after having a great start and looking to be in position for a strong top ten. Stepping under the tape and calling it a day may have given both of them an edge the next day, where they finished 2nd and 6th respectively. Redemption came quickly for both, but the loss of points has them much farther down the standings than they should be. Turner made it known that he's out to win races, not just fight for table scraps. At Wissahickon, he was active the entire race and quite aggressive with his lines. Good quality racing.
Rounding out the bottom of the top ten, either in points or in the day's racing were Mike Mihalik, Fatmarc, and HVB's Jim Mudd.
Thursday, October 18, 2007
2007 Granogue Cyclocross Preview
1. Evan Ellicott 33 Tacoma Park, MD
Ellicott is an incredibly strong rider and the top returner from last year's B race at Granogue. Though he only raced three times in the MAC last season, Granogue was actually his worst performance (4th). He was runner-up at Lower Allen as well as the season ending Capital Cross Classic. A horrific crash at the Tour de Toona this year sidlined him until last weekend when he finished 5th in A race at Iron Cross Lite. He made a transfer this year to team n-tieractive / Bike Doctor-Waldorf.
2. Daniel Brill 35 South River, NJ
Riding for Team Beacon again this season, Brill will be trying to improve ever so slightly and pick up that elusive win. Last season he finished no worse than 13th and as high as 5th at Granogue. He's a true Stalwart of the MAC and a force to be reckoned with. Not only that, but this year he's old enough to race Masters--at least after he gets to his unfinished business in the B Race.
3. Ethan Townsend 24 Wilmington, DE
There are few on the East coast who can match the starts of this local rider. As a member of the DCCofD as well as the powerful C3-Sollay.com team, he's out to prove this year that he can do more than take home the first lap preme. He finished 9th last season at Granogue, but this season he's already won twice on the MABRA circuit, taking the top step of the podium at Charm City as well as Hagerstown. With the inside scoop on the course, there's little doubt that E-Town will be in the lead group when the going gets tough.
4. Jeremy Dunn 27 South Boston, MA
Any rider making the trek down from Southie each weekend of the MAC should be feared and Dunn is no exception. Last season he got better and better each week, eventually racing in to top form and stealing two wins from the Mid Atlantic on a muddy New Jersey weekend. With Granogue expected to be dry and as fast as ever, that doesn't favor him, but with results like his and did I mention he's from South Boston? Watch out. He's also battle-tested having finished just behind Lyne Bessette up at New England Worlds. He races for Cambridge Bicycle / Igleheart Frames, the bike shop nearest to my alma mater, MIT.
5. Eric Linder 28 Baltimore, MD
The only man to interrupt Townsend's streak of MABRA victories was this man. Riding in green and black for the always strong HVB team, Eric Linder is their man for the B Series this year. He's got big shoes to fill, taking over for last year's MAC Series winner Greg Lindstrom and MABRA series winner Todd Hesel. With his performances so far, he's proven he's up to the challenge, but we'll have to wait and see what he can do on the MAC stage.
6. Marc Vettori 36 Elkton, MD
Easily the biggest celebrity rolling up to the start line at Granogue this year is Fatmarc Vettori. He too has moved over to the C3-Sollay.com squad this season and has made quite the impact in the MABRA Masters B category. Each week he finished on a different step of the podium, starting with a win at Charm City, and each week the press kept giving this man the win. He's so popular he wins without even being the first across the line. Is it the moviestar good looks, the lack of a pink helmet, or the coach? Everyone wants to know. Maybe we'll find out here on his home course. Last year he was 8th.
7. Erik Leaver 36 Silver Spring, MD
Fresh off his MABRA B series victory two years ago, last year didn't see much of Leaver on the MAC circuit. When it did, he did well, finishing third at the epic Highland Park race and 8th in the Beacon sand. It's hard to tell what form he has so far this season, but Leaver is a crafty veteran with plenty of skill for this race. Not having raced Granogue before may leave him at a disadvantage early on, but once he figures out the track, we might see the NCVC red and white at the front of the main field.
8. Kevin Kralik 23 Philadelphia, PA
Here's another top racer who benefited from that muddy New Jersey weekend last year, finishing 2nd and 3rd and Guy's and Evo. But he's not just a mud rider, he's already won once this season at Whirlybird and last season he won at Nittany Lion Cross. Other than those races, he's mostly an unknown rider, having no recorded experience on or off road outside of cyclocross season. There's no telling what to expect from this rider, but it would be a mistake to count him out when he's done so well on so little racing.
9. Patrick Bradley 17 Richwood, NJ
This is another Team Beacon rider with a lot to prove. Last season he won the C race and had a solid first season amongst the Killer B's. Now that he's added the muscle that comes with age, he's shown already this year that he's made the leap to be one of the top juniors (see also Gerlak and Bahnson) in this field. Can he win? Well, he's certainly lacking experience and the results, so we'll have to see. But there's no doubt that Bradley will be in the mix all season long.
10. Mike Stubna 31 Philadelphia, PA
It's a little odd to see such a strong road rider in the B field, but that's where we find Mike Stubna. He's well-known for his exploits on the powerful Meredith Group-GPOA road squad and now it looks as though he's out to prove himself in the MAC. Two years ago, he was experimenting in the elite field, but since he's been out of the cyclocross for a year, fighting amongst the other sandbaggers may be just what he needs to get his groove back. When he does, you'd better be ready.
11. Marc Bavineau 31 Beverly, MA
Bavineau proved he is amongst the best when he finished 15th at Nationals (B) last year. The only man in this field to beat him there was Ellicott. But there's no telling what we'll get from this New England rider. He narrowly missed out on a top ten at Gloucester last weekend, so we'll assume that he's battle hardened and not quite yet on top form. Will his introduction to the MAC go well? Plenty of Mid Atlantic racers are hoping to send him up the Jersey Turnpike empty handed. He races for Essex County Velo.
12. Morgan Gerlak 15 Baltimore, MD
Even at 15, Gerlak has acheived more notable results than most riders ever will, but there's still one result that he'd like to have and that's a B series win. He's been close now for a while, finishing second last week at Iron Cross Lite, and at last year's Evo MAC race. Is this the year that Morgan seals the deal on a win? It's hard to say with such top flight talent on his own team (C3). But he's got some of the best handling skills around and more experience on these MAC courses than just about anyone. With the engine getting better and better each year, I think we all know better than to count him out because of his age. Last year, he was 19th at Granogue.
13. Jeff Bahnson 14 Newark, DE
Trying to make a name for himself the way Morgan Gerlak has done, Bahnson showed he's capable at Charm City this year. At 14, the youngest rider in the race, he finished on the wide side of the podium and took home some schwag. He's young and inexperienced, so Granogue probably won't get his first B win this year, but it can't be too long before he's pushing the pace at the front of the field. He rides for C2S/Henry's Bikes. It's hard to believe this was him two year's ago.
Monday, October 15, 2007
I'm at least well rested, but I think now I'm going to throw in some anaerobic work tomorrow afternoon and then commence the rest week of spinning and skills work that I originally had planned. It'll probably be 3 sets of 4x90s all out. I figure if I do this, I'll stop panicking about my fitness going into this weekend, the first of the MAC series. I need to be on my game for that since I won't be getting a call-up and the comp will be fierce.
Thursday, October 11, 2007
Tuesday, October 09, 2007
According to an article I remember reading in VeloNews, and available for free over at JBV Coaching, this workout is from Tim Johnson. I figure, if he likes it, then it's good enough for me. It goes: 3 sets of 8x45s hard, with 1 min rest between intervals, and 5 min rest between sets. These efforts are above LT and are intended to work my anaerobic capacity. It's the first workout of its kind I've done this season.
Well, I can say that I definitely recommend this one. It made me hurt as much as I've ever hurt in a non-racing, non-climbing situation. I can also see why having a Powermeter makes doing workouts like these so much more precise. Being a track runner, I always had distance and time to gauge effort from one interval to the next and from one workout to the next. But doing these efforts for time on unequal elevation profiles, the only real gauge I have is my "feel" for how hard I'm working. That makes it difficult to really hone in on how hard I should be going in the first set such that my final set is still quality. Today, I felt like the final four of my third set were a bit lacking and that's probably due to my inexperience with anaerobic workouts on the bike.
Right now, I just want to feel the hurt as much as possible. My embarrassing road "season" has left me feeling pretty inadequate as far as fitness is concerned. So until I'm racing consistently this season, I'll probably remain paranoid about getting dropped due to being out of shape. This being the third "Build" week in my season schedule, now is the time to suffer and suffer I will. Bring it on.
Sunday, October 07, 2007
I had another good warmup on the roads today. My mind wasn't in the best of places for this one though. Winning yesterday gave me a positive boost, but it made me put a lot of pressure on myself that I hadn't really expected to have until the MAC starts up. My legs were understandably tired from the previous day's effort, but I felt good enough to be aiming for another win. I got on the front row again for this one, but the result was quite different. I had at least as good a start as yesterday, but this time I was third or fourth wheel rather than taking the holeshot. Since this course was much more technical than yesterday's, that was cause for immediate concern. I knew there was no way I could be a follower and place as high as I wanted.
One sandy section in the woods after the big hill was torn up from all the racing yesterday and so I elected to run that every time after the first lap. I stupidly tried to ride it even though I'd failed in warmups and I got gapped just a bit. I made up most of that gap back on the flat sections, but they were incredibly bumpy sections of grass that made it difficult to easily gain ground. Going into the other woods section, I took a horrible line, got passed by a few folks and found myself way overgeared. I fixed the problem relatively fast, but by that point, the front group had put significant time into me. I thought I might get it back when we hit the road, but the gap was too large, Lindstrom, Bradshaw, and another rider were up ahead.
Today's course, along with being much more technical, eliminated a huge power section and instead switched back and forth on itself to the point where I was forgetting which part of the course came next. I was riding myself into a daze and struggling to hold position. I believe that initially I was in no-mans land between the lead three and the rest of the field. I was working hard in attempting to crawl forwards in position, but I started to realize I was losing the battle when I became part of a group from behind me.
This group consisted of myself and three other riders and it was quickly understood, once we passed a guy falling off the lead pace, that we would be racing for third place. Four guys duking it out for a spot on the podium is a brutal affair. It's even more brutal when you feel as though you must lead every technical section to allow your lack of skills to slow the group. So for several laps, that's exactly what I did. I would go just fast enough that everytime we got to the horrible offcamber and 'S'-turn, I was in the lead. And everytime we had to make our way around a very tricky sandy turn, I was in the lead. And everytime we went into the final woods section, I forced myself to the front.
Well, that worked for a while. But at somewhere around two laps to go, my group mates got wiser. I think the realized my weakness and started fighting for position going into the technical sections. At least twice I was passed, as we hit the sand going into the final woods. It was so frustrating because I kept trying to find a line that would allow me to keep speed going and I couldn't. I was lucky enough that I had enough gas to get back with whoever had passed me then each time back on the road, but I knew in the back of my mind that eventually that wouldn't be the case. It also wasn't allowing me to put any time into them on power sections. Oh, how I was wishing we still had the lap around the field today!
With one lap to go, I was still in my place at the front of our pack, but I was hurting bad. I got no real gap up the mountain and I lost one spot before the off camber and 'S'-turn, but I held on and kept digging. I forced my way to the front one last time and led up the log run-up. But that's when two of the riders started to get very aggressive and in the sandy turn that had been giving me fits all day, they both went for the kill and passed me. I had no choice but to watch a little gap form and then attack like mad to pass them before we went into the woods the last time. Well, I attacked and passed them, but I must have let up a bit too soon, or they were expecting my frantic pace because they attacked back and all three riders passed me again! I was suddenly at the back of the four person pack I'd led for what had felt like an eternity. I knew that if I let any gap form I'd have to bury myself to get it back on the asphalt drag to the finish.
I watched in "horror" as Snoop, rode away from the other two in front of me and it was clear that the battle for third was over. It was going to be a three-way sprint for fourth. I lost time in the woods, but as soon as we hit pavement, I made up that ground and sat in the slipstream of the other two. I thought I had enough gas to win this sprint and I was very confident. I sat as patiently as I could and whe we saw the line, the race was on. The rider on second wheel (Cavanaugh) made his move and I made mine, but I had more ground to cover, and he had a surprisingly good finishing kick. We both stormed past the lead rider (Wolff) and towards the line with him winning by just a touch. I finished fifth.
Looking back over the course of the race, I have to say that I should have been at least third if I'd played my cards right. I worked too hard for too long and in the end I had burnt nearly all my matches. The competition was some of the best I've had in bike racing and I took up residence in the pain cave for most of the race. The technical sections of the course were my undoing and the mistake in the woods in the early going eliminated any hope of a repeat win. It's frustrating to "lose" a winnable race that early on, but sometimes that's how it goes. I didn't have the power I needed to make my strong sections hurt others and instead I had to use those sections to hang on for dear life. This was easily the most technical dry course I've ever raced and I did ok. Had I won that sprint into the woods the last time, I'm confident I could have improved at least one place. All in all, a great race for the early season--perfect to force me to work on my weaknesses.
Saturday, October 06, 2007
After previewing the course, Jess lined up for her first cyclocross race ever. I've been pushing her to give it a try for a long while and I was pretty excited to see her finally give in and toe the line. This course was anything but easy for Jess. There was one very steep but short sandy hill that was unrideable and barely walkable for us mortals. And there was also a 20% grade hill that was large and quite daunting. Most of the women in this race ended up walking rather than running up the hill by the end.
Even though this course wasn't ideal for her, Jess put forth a great effort and placed fourth out of eight riders, 2:50 back from the winner. With one more lap, I'm confident she would have been on the podium. I'm equally as confident that if she were to keep racing, she would have some decent success. She's strong and more competitive that she gives herself credit for. She's also fairly skilled for her level on technical sections.
But I think this was probably Jess' first and last 'cross race. She truly seems to prefer watching me and being a part of the scene rather than actually racing. She said she's glad she did it since it gives her even more appreciation of what racing is like and what we all put ourselves through. But in the end, she didn't feel like she had the desire to race that have. It's also a good monetary decision considering how much I spend on entry fees. Doubling that would be an enormous cost.
From the gun, this race was a total and complete surprise to me. I clipped in immediately and started the way I'd done on Friday doing openers with George. I hammered to the front and was a bit taken aback with how easily I took the holeshot. It was so easy that I had to look back and wonder if perhaps I was going a bit too hard. Before we hit the first turn at the end of the building, I decided that I'd better keep the lead and see what I could do with it. I figured if I led up the small hillock and up the mountain, I'd probably be all set to lead the entire first lap. I did just that, electing to run the mountain and riding the off-camber coming out of the hilltop fairly well. I had a crew of riders right behind me and I was defintitely feeling the effects of setting the early pace. Last year at IC Lite, I'd taken a similar start of setting the early tempo, but the difference here was that I don't yet have confidence in my fitness. I'm only a few weeks removed from being pulled from crits.
But there I was, leading the race. As soon as we hit the asphalt coming out of the woods by the start line and returning towards the finish, I elected to let one of the followers lead us into the wind. I wasn't brazen enough to push the pace for too long. I followed close behind the new leader and I realized that I was terrified of getting gapped. I didn't have the confidence to follow the lead and feel comfortable, so I went back to the front and led most of the lap again. I repeated the switch off on the asphalt with a different leader, but this time I dove into the corner coming off the asphalt and went back to the lead as soon as we hit the grass. From there, the race was truly on.
I ran the mountain the first two times, but on the third I decided to start riding it. I was followed in hot pursuit by Andrew Grabarek of Keltic Construction. He followed my every move and somehow we managed to commandeer the lead and create a large gap between ourselves and the rest of the riders. I remember hearing the announcer comment on us switching off the lead one time through the asphalt and also hearing Mel yell to me that, "You've got a gap, keep it going."
With just over two laps to go, disaster struck for Grabarek. Coming into the barriers, I led and as soon as I crossed them, I heard him go down. I glanced back only to see him lying on the ground with his bike. I wasted no time in attacking all out to put time into him. As I was heading into the singletrack woods section before the start line, I noticed that he wasn't getting up and that the race was mine to lose. When I came through the start line I had two laps to go and I had to focus on keeping the lead as best I could. I had Jess giving me the gap back to the next group of riders and it was 30 seconds. It dipped down to 25 at some point during the penultimate lap, but I wasn't worried. I kept riding my race and focusing on keeping a solid pace in the flats and staying alert through the technical terrain.
Jess said later that she didn't know when I was on my last lap and that she started to get worried when the gap began to drop some. But I had things under control by then and I was merely trying to avoid pinch flatting on some on the rocky gully and a few of the exposed roots and cut trees. I kept the pace under control and as soon as I hit the asphalt the final time, I gave it full gas to ensure the victory. The second place rider ended up thirteen seconds back according to the results. That was a bit closer than I'd intended to let him get, but comfortable enough.
It's odd to get a win like this so early into a season in which I entered with no real fitness to speak of. Winning at Charm City last season was a big surprise, but I knew I was on top form coming in to that. It's an even bigger surprise to take the win by such an easy margin. I've never won a 'cross race before the final sprint. I was definitely aided by the crash behind me and the field wasn't the best I'll see. But a win is a win and I beat some good riders. With myself considering this course to be fairly technical, I'm extremely pleased to come out on top. It's a nice gift to keep the motivation high as I enter a weekend off from racing before the MAC season begins.
And if that wasn't enough, we'd parked next to Ryan Trebon, the US National Champion and his parter in crime, Barry Wicks. They were unloading their rental minivan and pulling out more carbon than a DC Velo Sunday ride. Dugasts, FSA Carbon wheels, sweet Kore brakes and the biggest freakin' orange frames around. George, conversationalist extraordinaire, struck up a conversation with them and we chatted for a bit. Very cool. Trebon showed me the new clearance for the chainrings on the 2008 Konas and remarked that he missed his Spooky brakes, but that the Kore ones were working great. He mentioned that he is leaving for Belgium on Monday and coming back for Natz, the USGP in Louisville and Portland. Wicks will be stepping it up to take that series in his absence.
The Elite Women's race was rather boring. We got to see Katie Compton absolutely destroy the field and any hope of real competition up front was dashed when Lyne Bessette had a chain failure.
The Elite Men's race, however, did NOT disappoint. The start was incredible. They were a true thundering herd coming towards us all and as soon as they touched grass, the dust was flying everywhere. Trebon had the holeshot and was closely followed by Erwin . . .
To be continued when I have some more free time. Plenty more pictures and race summaries to come.
Bikes:
Friday, October 05, 2007
The drive was surprisingly easy and we were there in around six hours. After unloading the car, George and I changed into our kits and hit the road on our 'cross bikes. We rode along Soundview Ave. and out to the Horton Point Lighthouse. We had to take a moment and enjoy the sun beginning to set below the clouds over Long Island Sound. Once we did, we turned for home and started doing starts to open up the legs for tomorrow. We alternated being the starter and experimented with different gears. This was my first time practicing starts this year, and I was encouraged at my ability to get off the line. George and I both came away feeling great about our legs and psyched to be racing on the same track as the World Champion.
Jess and I whipped up a simple pasta dish and we all chowed down. After that George set up some DVD's of the cyclocross world championships while I worked on getting Jess' bike race-ready. All that took was removing the rack and putting on my Grifo clincher tires. The weekend is already shaping up to be a cyclocross camp for the three of us.
Monday, October 01, 2007
On Wednesday night I went over to Pat's house and changed out the bearings in my Cane Creek S2 headset to see if that might aid in alleviating some brake chatter. It did get rid of an elusive rattle that I'd been hearing when dropping the front end (yes, the headset was checked for play). But I didn't really notice any change in chatter. The front end felt more solid and I had more confidence in it, but not the huge difference I was looking for.
On Friday night I played around with raising the yolk on my brakes. I found that raising the yolk did more to stop some of the brake chatter I've had than any other adjustment that I've made. Really. There's still a tiny bit at low speeds and I haven't spent a lot of time with the pads and rims wet, but I'm encouraged so far.
I also found out that regular brake cable (road nor MTB) will not work as a straddle cable for Empella Frogleg brakes. The ball end is too large for the opening. Regular cables work fine on Paul's, however. My question is whether there is any difference between what cyclocrossworld.com calls 'Empella/Spooky Straddle Cables' and dubs, "Hard to find," and just plain ol' derailleur cable? I can find no difference between the original straddle cables I got with the set and the derailleur cable that I replaced it with--other than the length. But I did talk to a mechanic finally and he said that the difference is in the thickness and derailleur cable is a bit too thin in some instances to bear the load of braking. So I picked up some of the fancy brake cable and now I'm all set.
The most interesting mechanical development this week was the arrival of the Spot Brand guards on Friday. Initially I swapped out both Carbon guards for the two new Spot guards and the setup was pretty sweet. Unfortunately it did add 4 oz, but it was quite robust. But one other difference between the Spot and the Carbon is the thickness. The Spot Brand is roughly twice the thickness and so the clearance between the inner guard and the frame was almost (but not quite) nil. Doing starts on Saturday I could hear it rub the frame when I stomped on the left side. With my frame being thin-walled Scandium Aluminum, I wasn't to keen on possibly scoring the metal.
Solution? I left the Spot on the outside and put a Carbon guard on the inside, using two 0.6 mm thick washers on each of the five chainring bolts. I think that will be my long term solution. If I have any trouble with the Carbon guard, I'll have to take the Spot Brand guard over to a belt sander and add a chamfer. It won't take much to get the necessary clearance. Looking at Peter Nicoll's bike on Saturday, I noticed that the Wetzikon guard has such a chamfer. The appeared to be made out of the same material, and with the Wetzikon having the holes drilled for weight I'd give it the edge (ha ha). In defense, my Spot guard was about $10 cheaper.